Loading...
Loading...
Flat searchable index of all court filings, evidence, and public records.
157 of 157 documents
DHCR Overcharge Complaint (NV410032B) — DHCR Rent Administrator order terminating the decreased-services proceeding NV410032B filed by tenants. Relief denied.
109E9 LLC v. Shiras Patterson Beckwith (LT-306106-25) — North Brooklyn Boat Club records showing Beckwith's address at 131 Calyer Street, Brooklyn — further evidence of non-primary residence at the SRO.
People of the State of New York v. Remigiusz Chlapek — 26-count Grand Jury indictment against Remigiusz Chlapek for sex trafficking, promoting prostitution, and witness tampering. Chlapek is held at Rikers Island.
People of the State of New York v. Remigiusz Chlapek — Court appearance record for Grand Jury indictment 70317-26.
People of the State of New York v. Remigiusz Chlapek — Charges record for Grand Jury indictment 70317-26.
119 Freeman Realty Corp. v. Amy Gartrell (LT-328066-25) — Gartrell's answer denying non-primary residence allegations, filed by Himmelstein McConnell Gribben & Joseph LLP. Includes counterclaim for attorneys' fees.
119 Freeman Realty Corp. v. Amy Gartrell (LT-328066-25) — Second court-approved stipulation between the parties.
HPD v. Michael Geylik (OATH 1984/25) — ALJ Christine Stecura's Report and Recommendation following a six-day administrative trial on the revocation of the Certificate of No Harassment.
119 Freeman Realty Corp. v. Amy Gartrell (LT-328066-25) — First court-approved stipulation between the parties.
119 Freeman Realty Corp. v. Amy Gartrell (LT-328066-25) — Notice of appearance by Himmelstein McConnell Gribben & Joseph LLP (Catharine A. Grad) as attorneys for respondent Amy Gartrell.
109E9 LLC v. Shiras Patterson Beckwith (LT-306106-25) — Chase bank records documenting Beckwith's financial transactions with Chlapek, raising money laundering concerns.
119 Freeman Realty Corp. v. Amy Gartrell (LT-328066-25) — Second notice of petition.
119 Freeman Realty Corp. v. Amy Gartrell (LT-328066-25) — Affidavit of service documenting attempts to serve Gartrell at 119 Freeman Street. Process server rang bell/knocked with no answer on multiple attempts before affixing papers to the door.
People of the State of New York v. Remigiusz Chlapek — Court appearance record for People v. Chlapek criminal mischief case CR-007659-25NY.
People of the State of New York v. Remigiusz Chlapek — Criminal charges record for People v. Chlapek criminal mischief case CR-007659-25NY.
HPD v. Michael Geylik (OATH 1984/25) — HPD's post-trial closing memorandum submitted following the six-day OATH administrative trial.
HPD v. Michael Geylik (OATH 1984/25) — Respondent's post-trial closing brief submitted following the six-day OATH administrative trial.
109E9 LLC v. Remigiusz Chlapek — Non-Payment #2 (LT-321176-25) — Second non-payment petition against Remigiusz Chlapek (Unit 2D), filed December 17, 2025, seeking $3,600 in arrears.
People of the State of New York v. Remigiusz Chlapek — 14-day rent demand served on Remigiusz Chlapek (Unit 2D) for rent arrears.
109E9 LLC v. Shiras Patterson Beckwith (LT-306106-25) — Beckwith's response to notice to produce documents in the non-primary residence proceeding.
109E9 LLC v. Shiras Patterson Beckwith (LT-306106-25) — Beckwith's responses and objections to interrogatories in the non-primary residence proceeding.
119 Freeman Realty Corp. v. Amy Gartrell (LT-328066-25) — Non-primary residence holdover petition filed by 119 Freeman Realty Corp against Amy Gartrell for the rent-stabilized apartment at 119 Freeman Street, Apt. 2R, Brooklyn. Alleges Gartrell primarily resides at 109 E. 9th Street, Apt. 2E.
119 Freeman Realty Corp. v. Amy Gartrell (LT-328066-25) — Notice of petition served on Amy Gartrell.
119 Freeman Realty Corp. v. Amy Gartrell (LT-328066-25) — Statement of authorization for the holdover proceeding.
HPD v. Michael Geylik (OATH 1984/25) — Respondent's court submission volume VI for the HPD v. Geylik OATH trial.
109E9 LLC v. Shiras Patterson Beckwith (LT-306106-25) — Court decision and order in the non-primary residence eviction proceeding against Beckwith.
HPD v. Michael Geylik (OATH 1984/25) — Respondent's court submission volume V for the HPD v. Geylik OATH trial.
109E9 LLC v. Shiras Patterson Beckwith (LT-306106-25) — Parking ticket records for vehicles associated with Patterson Beckwith — 170 of 174 violations in Brooklyn/Queens, contradicting primary residence claim at the Manhattan SRO.
109E9 LLC v. Shiras Patterson Beckwith (LT-306106-25) — Affidavit of Michael Geylik submitted in support of the non-primary residence eviction case against Beckwith.
109E9 LLC v. Shiras Patterson Beckwith (LT-306106-25) — Signed affidavit of Mint Tam submitted in the non-primary residence eviction proceeding.
HPD v. Michael Geylik (OATH 1984/25) — Respondent's court submission volume IV for the HPD v. Geylik OATH trial.
HPD v. Michael Geylik (OATH 1984/25) — Respondent's court submission volume III for the HPD v. Geylik OATH trial.
People of the State of New York v. Remigiusz Chlapek — Criminal history record information — CHRS Job 10929523 data sheet for Remigiusz Chlapek.
119 Freeman Realty Corp. v. Amy Gartrell (LT-328066-25) — Notice to terminate tenancy based on non-primary residence. Enumerates evidence that Gartrell primarily resides at 109 E. 9th St: vehicle registration, voter registration, financial records, and partner Beckwith's lease/utilities all at that address. Building personnel had not seen her on a daily basis for at least one year.
HPD v. Michael Geylik (OATH 1984/25) — Respondent's court submission volume II for the HPD v. Geylik OATH trial.
HPD v. Michael Geylik (OATH 1984/25) — Notarized affidavit of Yousef Girgist Salama submitted in support of respondent's case.
HPD v. Michael Geylik (OATH 1984/25) — Respondent's court submission volume I for the HPD v. Geylik OATH trial.
HPD v. Michael Geylik (OATH 1984/25) — HPD's proposed analysis of exhibits 1 through 37 submitted for the OATH administrative trial.
People of the State of New York v. Remigiusz Chlapek — Temporary order of protection issued against Remigiusz Chlapek, protecting building owner Michael Geylik. Conditions include stay-away from Geylik's home, school, business, place of employment, and 109 East 9th Street; no contact by any means; no third-party contact; refrain from assault, stalking, harassment, and all criminal offenses against Geylik. Issued as a condition of recognizance. Valid until October 23, 2025.
109E9 LLC v. Remigiusz Chlapek — Non-Payment #1 (LT-301837-25) — Non-payment petition against Remigiusz Chlapek (Unit 2D) seeking $5,850 in arrears (Dec 2023 – Dec 2024 at $450/month).
109E9 LLC v. Judy Lucille Sabin — Non-Payment (LT-301839-25) — Court papers for LT-301839-25 (Judy Lucille Sabin) produced by HPD in discovery for OATH Index No. 1984/25. Petition seeks $6,533.52 plus interest from July 1, 2021.
HPD v. Michael Geylik (OATH 1984/25) — OATH withdrawal of prosecution for ECB Violation 391-310-83H (work without permit for emergency shoring).
109E9 LLC v. James T. Hicks (LT-306109-25) — Non-primary residence holdover petition against James Hicks (Unit 4B) and Jane Doe (later identified as O'Hara Mars).
109E9 LLC v. James T. Hicks (LT-306109-25) — Court file for LT-306109-25 produced by HPD in discovery for OATH Index No. 1984-25.
109E9 LLC v. Shiras Patterson Beckwith (LT-306106-25) — Non-primary residence holdover petition against Patterson Beckwith (Unit 2E).
109E9 LLC v. Shiras Patterson Beckwith (LT-306106-25) — InfoTactic Group expert witness report analyzing 47,390 security camera clips showing Beckwith present only 124 out of 1,104 days (~1.3% of total time).
109E9 LLC v. Shiras Patterson Beckwith (LT-306106-25) — Court file for LT-306106-25 produced by HPD in discovery for OATH Index No. 1984-25.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Initial petition filed by tenants in HP proceeding against the building owner.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Proposed order to show cause submitted with the petition.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Application to waive court filing fees.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — HPD property registration for 109 East 9th Street.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Department of Buildings violation records for the building.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Department of Buildings stop work orders issued for the building.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Court-signed order to show cause.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Proof of service of court papers on the respondent.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Certificates of mailing for service of process.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Geylik's answer to the petition, including counterclaims against the tenants.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — First court decision and order in the proceeding.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Court-ordered inspection request for the building.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Notice of motion filed in the proceeding.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Attorney affirmation in support of the motion.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Proposed notice of inspection submitted with the motion.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Notice to produce documents served on the opposing party.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Design professional's sealed certification.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Deed from prior owner Sheyman.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — HPD registration for a related property at 37 West End Avenue.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Deed transferring 109 East 9th Street to Geylik / 109E9 LLC.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Summary of HPD violations for the building.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Photographs of conditions in apartments 1A and 3B.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Legal memorandum submitted in support of the motion.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Second court decision and order in the proceeding.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Court-ordered inspection report for apartment 2B.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Court-ordered inspection report for apartment 2A.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Court-ordered inspection report for apartment 4A.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Court-ordered inspection report for apartment 4C.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Court-ordered inspection report for apartment 3A.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Court-ordered inspection report for non-vacant room on the 3rd floor.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Court-ordered inspection report for 4th floor public area.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Court-ordered inspection report for 2nd floor public area.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Court-ordered inspection report for the stairwell.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Court-ordered inspection report for a 2nd floor unit.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Geylik's cross-motion in response to tenants' motion.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Attorney affirmation in support of the cross-motion.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Personal affirmation of Michael Geylik submitted with Motion 2.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Personal affirmation of Y. Geylik submitted with Motion 2.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — HPD property information submitted as exhibit in Motion 2.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Corrected affirmation in opposition to the cross-motion.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Anti-harassment checklist filed as an exhibit.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — DOB job summary filed as an exhibit.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — 2021 mortgage documents filed as an exhibit.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Affirmation of Michael Geylik filed as exhibit in Motion 2.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Affirmation of Mint Tan filed as exhibit in Motion 2.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Certificate of No Harassment application filed as exhibit.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Reply affirmation in support of the cross-motion.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — First court-approved stipulation between the parties.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Second court-approved stipulation between the parties.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Stipulation for adjournment of proceedings.
Dukleth, Hall, Beckwith, Sabin & Chlapek v. 109E9 LLC (LT-307504-25) — Third court decision and order in the proceeding.
109E9 LLC v. Remigiusz Chlapek — Non-Payment #1 (LT-301837-25) — Court papers for LT-301837-25 produced by HPD in discovery for OATH Index No. 1984/25.
Notice — Letter from Michael Geylik to Thomas Dukleth requesting removal of personal items from the fourth-floor refrigerator room to allow DOB-ordered structural probing.
Notice — Letter requesting removal of personal property from hallways and Unit 2B for DOB-directed structural evaluation.
Engineering — Engineering report and photographic documentation supporting the vacate determination for Unit 4C due to structural concerns.
Expert Report — Steel Core Engineering report exhibits documenting the structural condition of 109 East 9th Street, submitted November 11, 2024.
Inspection — DOB inspection report 24043r0 from May 17, 2024 documenting building conditions during the structural evaluation period.
XLSX — Spreadsheet listing 15 HPD violations for 109 East 9th Street as of February 18, 2026.
HPD — HPD notice confirming that two violations have been deemed corrected, plus eCertify signed violation certification and HPD violations document HPD_11287.
Correspondence — Structural engineering correspondence related to the ongoing DOB FEU structural evaluation and permanent repair planning.
HPD Complaints — Documentation of HPD heat complaints including below-50-degree bathroom readings, photos, and videos from December 2025.
Complaints — Text messages between Sabin and Mars regarding noise complaints about Zachary Hall, police calls, and surveillance footage from December 2025.
PDF — Application for Certificate of No Harassment filed by Michael Geylik on August 14, 2023. Documents building configuration, occupancy roster, and ownership history. Part of HPD Discovery Response for OATH Index 1984-25.
Historical Analysis — Historical construction analysis of the 1850s-era building, 19th-century corner lot building analysis, and comprehensive structural analysis diagram (25-0706) documenting the building's original construction methods and current condition.
Violations — Additional DOB and ECB violations issued November 7, 2025, including summonses 39166234X, 39166238N, 39166217Y, 39166312M, violation VI025-02512, firestopping violation letter, and stop work order complaints at BIN 1008963.
Photo/Report — Documentation of bedbug conditions related to the Chlapek criminal mischief case and tenant harassment proceedings. Zachary Hall (Unit 4D) has repeatedly complained about bedbugs in the building.
Email — Email correspondence regarding Bobby Rich, the alleged middleman subletting Hicks' Unit 4B. Includes December 2024 and October 2025 exchanges.
Video — Security camera recordings from multiple cameras (CAM 01, CAM 04, CAM 07, storefront 180) documenting incidents including garbage disposal, illegal entry, police responses, and unauthorized building access. Includes phone call recording with exterminator.
Expert Analysis — Analysis identifying critical gaps in Friedman's structural evaluation of 109 East 9th Street, including detailed spreadsheet of deficiencies.
DHCR — DHCR rent overcharge complaint NV410032B filed against the building owner. Includes docket received November 28, 2025 and preliminary response with extension request filed January 26, 2026.
DHCR — Division of Housing and Community Renewal rent registration records, rent roll report, and case history from HPD discovery (OATH 1984-25).
Complaints — Complete DOB complaint log for BIN 1008963, plus individual complaint records including #1682501, #1684322, #1693900, and #1694293.
Exhibits — Compilation of historic DOB exhibits documenting the building’s regulatory history.
DOB Audit — Complete email chain between DOB Forensic Engineer Philip Ng and the building owner regarding the special audit of permits M01181265-I1 and M01098599-I1, including audit objections filed by the owner's engineer.
Violations — ECB violations and cure certificates documenting decades-old violations resolved under new ownership.
Email — Email correspondence regarding Bobby Rich, the alleged middleman subletting James Hicks’ Unit 4B at ~$500/month.
Email — Email correspondence regarding the sale of 109 East 9th Street.
Email — Email thread regarding Unit 4B at 109 East 9th Street, occupied by James Hicks.
Email — Email correspondence threads with Zachary Hall covering building updates, extermination requests, rent checks, smoke detectors, and HPD/DOB complaints.
Work Orders — DOB Emergency Work Order FEU-103-01PN for emergency shoring, plus LAA job sign-offs.
Public Records — Beckwith & Gartrell’s public wedding registry containing admissions about owning a Pittsburgh rowhouse and having an apartment full of everything they need.
Registration — ICARD building registration document #628600.
PI Investigation — Private investigation materials from Info Tactic Group including property records for 7485 and 7487 Delmar Way (Pittsburgh), surveillance photographs, and CHRS criminal history data sheet.
Messages — Internal text message correspondence with James Hicks (Unit 4B).
Messages — Internal text message correspondence with Patterson Beckwith (Unit 2E).
Messages — Internal text message correspondence with Remigiusz Chlapek (Unit 2D).
Messages — Internal text message correspondence with Thomas Scarlett (Unit 4B).
Messages — Internal text message correspondence involving Zachary Hall.
Maintenance — Waste collection agreement, CityPay sanitation record, locksmith invoice, and lobby garbage schedule.
PI Findings — InfoTactic Group’s expert witness report analyzing 47,390 security camera clips over three years. Concludes Beckwith was present at 109 E 9th St on only 124 out of 1,104 days.
Police — Police incident documentation involving Zachary Hall, including NYPD visit screenshots and girlfriend Kelly Kim evidence.
Structural Analysis — Structural engineering report documenting the building’s condition, including confirmed framing failure.
DOB Filing — Request to Borough Commissioner to lift the hold on structural repair permit M01181265-I1, plus PER11 appointment requests for both M01098599-I1 and M01181265-I1.
Invoices — Individual pest control invoices from NJB Pest Control (11 invoices) and All Out Bed Bug Exterminators documenting regular pest management services. Supplements the consolidated pest control letters.
Pest Control — Pest control service letters and invoices documenting regular pest management, including response to bedbugs deliberately introduced by Remigiusz Chlapek (Unit 2D).
Property Records — Allegheny County deed records for 7485 and 7487 Delmar Way — two adjacent rowhouses owned by Beckwith while claiming an 80 sq ft SRO unit as primary residence.
Police — Judy Sabin's police reports filed against Zachary Hall, including the January 2020 stalking report and subsequent incidents.
Police — Restraining order received May 5, 2025, plus police call documentation and screenshots from multiple incidents at 109 East 9th Street.
Engineering — Multiple structural engineering investigation letters (September–November 2024), building safety letter, and structural drawings documenting the progression from initial crack report through confirmed framing failure.
Video Evidence — Security camera footage documenting Chlapek's activities including garbage disposal, breaking into a vacant unit, and incidents leading to arrest. Multiple camera angles from 109E9 CAM 01 and storefront cameras.
Affidavits — Notarized affidavits from witnesses including structural engineer (OATH 1984-25), Ali Atalay, Bruce Church, and Jesse Berlin — supporting the owner's case in various proceedings.
TakeRoot — CONH application materials, exhibits A–J, correspondence, and 37 building condition photographs submitted by TakeRoot Justice. Produced in HPD discovery (OATH 1984-25).
Messages — Text message correspondence between the building owner and Thomas Dukleth.
Messages — Complete text message correspondence between building management and Zachary Hall (Unit 4D) from March 2024 through April 2025, documenting tenant interactions and complaints.
Messages & Police — Text message correspondence involving Judy Sabin (Unit 3C), NYPD domestic incident report (Sabin v. Hall stalking, January 2020), and CONH 14-day notice.
PI Report & Vehicle Records — PI background report on Amy Gartrell (DMV-confirmed Brooklyn address), parking tickets for 4 vehicles (170 of 174 violations in Brooklyn/Queens), and Beckwith’s role as Co-President of the North Brooklyn Boat Club.
OpenGovNY — Business entity filing for the building's ownership LLC.
NYC OATH — Report and Recommendation by Administrative Law Judge Christine Stecura regarding HPD's case against the building owner.
NYC Property Portal — Official NYC property information for 109 East 9th Street.
ACRIS — Deed transfers, mortgage records, and other property filings.