Loading...
Loading...
Tenants — Unit 2E — Named Party
Named party in LT-306106-25 (Geylik v. Beckwith). Wife of Shiras Patterson Beckwith. Being sued by her own Brooklyn landlord, 119 Freeman Realty Corp, in a separate non-primary residence holdover proceeding (LT-328066-25/KI) for a rent-stabilized unit at 119 Freeman Street, Apt. 2R, Brooklyn. Her landlord alleges she primarily resides at 109 E. 9th Street, Apt. 2E — the same SRO unit at issue in Geylik v. Beckwith.
NYC Civil Court — Housing Part, County of New York — LT-306106-25
Active — discovery phase. Motion to dismiss denied Sep 16, 2025; discovery granted. PI report (Exhibit S-39) filed.
NYC Civil Court — Housing Part, County of Kings — LT-328066-25/KI
Active — filed by Gartrell’s Brooklyn landlord (119 Freeman Realty Corp); respondent represented by Himmelstein McConnell Gribben & Joseph LLP
Affidavit of service documenting attempts to serve Gartrell at 119 Freeman Street. Process server rang bell/knocked with no answer on multiple attempts before affixing papers to the door.
Non-primary residence holdover petition filed by 119 Freeman Realty Corp against Amy Gartrell for the rent-stabilized apartment at 119 Freeman Street, Apt. 2R, Brooklyn. Alleges Gartrell primarily resides at 109 E. 9th Street, Apt. 2E.
Notice to terminate tenancy based on non-primary residence. Enumerates evidence that Gartrell primarily resides at 109 E. 9th St: vehicle registration, voter registration, financial records, and partner Beckwith's lease/utilities all at that address. Building personnel had not seen her on a daily basis for at least one year.
InfoTactic Group’s expert witness report analyzing 47,390 security camera clips over three years. Concludes Beckwith was present at 109 E 9th St on only 124 out of 1,104 days.
Allegheny County deed records for 7485 and 7487 Delmar Way — two adjacent rowhouses owned by Beckwith while claiming an 80 sq ft SRO unit as primary residence.
PI background report on Amy Gartrell (DMV-confirmed Brooklyn address), parking tickets for 4 vehicles (170 of 174 violations in Brooklyn/Queens), and Beckwith’s role as Co-President of the North Brooklyn Boat Club.
Beckwith & Gartrell’s public wedding registry containing admissions about owning a Pittsburgh rowhouse and having an apartment full of everything they need.